When Eliot died, he was taken, not by a boatman or an angel, but by train to a place he had not expected to be taken because no one had ever told him that such a place existed.
The train ride went by so quickly that he had difficulty remembering it afterward. The sweeping view of wild, empty landscapes that had at first seemed so vivid to him broke down piece by piece into an obscure perception, at last taking on the semblance of a dream.
It wasn’t until he was being led out of the cave and into the chilled, open air that he first began to consolidate these experiences as they came to him, one after another. He looked around and found that he was among a herd of slow-moving people, all with their eyes on someone at the front of the procession—a man as far as he could tell.
Eliot could not see the man with any clarity, as he seemed to be shadowed against the light of the cave’s outlet. Above the sea of swaying heads, Eliot saw the man lift up a hand and beckon to the crowd with it.
“Keep up, folks,” he called. “Almost there, now.” His voice broke into an echo that swam along the deepening walls into darkness.
Eliot looked down at the dusty floor ridden with pebbles. He had not imagined it being anything like this. A little girl came up to him and tugged the sleeve of his sweater.
“What is it?” Eliot said.
“I can’t find my daddy,” she said.
Eliot took her hand in his and held it tight.
“I’ll help you look for him as soon as we get out of here,” he said.
“I don’t think he is here,” she said.
“Maybe not, but we’ll look… just to be sure. He may be with another group.”
The little girl seemed satisfied with this and stuck close to Eliot the rest of the way. When they came out into the light, Eliot realized that it wasn’t light at all. He didn’t know what it was because he’d never seen anything like it before.
“Is that a sky?” the girl asked.
“Doesn’t look like one,” he said.
Eliot and the little girl followed the crowd along a wide ledge overlooking an empty valley. The grass in the valley was a rich, dark green; from far off, the fields appeared both holy and at peace under the grey light that was not a sky.
“I’ve seen this place before,” the little girl said. “In a dream.”
“I think I have too,” Eliot said. He looked out beyond the sloping grass toward the high-rising cliffs guarding the valley on the far side. There was a dark recession high up in the face of the cliffs. Another tunnel or cave by the look of it.
Guardians were posted along the ledge to keep people on course. One of them heard Eliot and the little girl talking and snapped his finger at them.
“No talking during the procession,” he said.
Eliot remembered something being said earlier about the need for silence during the journey, but that had been right after… a train ride? He was, after all, still a baby in this new place.
“Why don’t they want us to talk?” the girl whispered after they had walked a ways.
Eliot shook his head. “Just the rules, I guess. What does your dad look like?”
“I… I don’t remember,” she said. Tears began to form in her eyes.
Eliot could hear her sniffling. For a moment, he wasn’t sure what to do, if anything. He kept walking, pulling her along with him as if he were a little boy dragging a stuffed animal. She continued to cry.
Eliot stopped, looked around, then knelt down beside her. His knee stuck through the hole in his jeans, grinding into the hard path. “Don’t worry,” he whispered. “We’ll find him. All right?”
She nodded, wiped her eyes. Eliot felt bad for lying, but he couldn’t stand to see the girl cry. Things were heavy enough without a child’s tears.
“Promise?” she asked.
Eliot looked into her sad eyes and felt something cold press against his heart. He had not anticipated that she’d ask him to give his word.
“Do not stop.” It was the same guardian from before.
Eliot got up and, taking the girl’s hand again, moved back into the solemn procession. They followed the ledge along the jagged cliff walls until the path opened out onto a flat shelf overlooking the valley. From his position in the rear of the group, Eliot could see that everyone was being rallied together on the shelf.
He felt the little girl’s eyes on him.
“What’s your name?” she whispered. He was glad that she seemed to have forgotten about the promise.
“Eliot,” he said without looking at her. “What’s yours?”
“Eliza,” she said. “Our names are alike.”
Eliot looked down, saw that she was smiling. He looked up to see another one of the guardians eyeing him suspiciously.
“I think we better keep quiet until this is over,” he said after they had safely passed beyond the guardian’s view. Eliza only nodded.
Strange girl, Eliot thought. He glanced down at her again, noticed that she was actually very pretty. He thought about her father and felt pain at the thought. She was so young…
He felt her hand tighten in his as they came to a halt on the wide ledge, then felt it tremble as a chill wind blew through the quiet throng. Eliot and Eliza were at the far back of the group and as such could not see over the crowd, stretching on before them like a field of somber statues. Nobody moved; nobody breathed.
“Eliot…” Eliza whispered.
He could tell that she was nervous. “Let’s just wait and see,” he said, trying to comfort her. He felt her hand loosen a bit.
Neither of them knew what to expect, but they both expected something. Amid the silence, they listened and waited.
Eliot saw a man step up onto a rocky platform overlooking the crowd; he could see the man clearly even from the back of the group. When the man spoke, Eliot recognized his voice. It was the same guide that had led them all to this point.
“All right, folks,” the guide said. “Pay close attention because I will not be repeating myself.” His voice carried over the precipice, echoing down into the valley.
“Most of you are probably wondering where you are,” he went on, “and with good reason. Well, let me start by saying that this is not Heaven.”
A gasp could be heard from a few people in the crowd. Eliot wasn’t surprised. It was obvious to him that this place was not Heaven… at least not the Heaven he had been taught about. He looked down at Eliza. She appeared calm, unmoved. He wondered if she even knew what Heaven was.
“It’s not Hell either,” the man quickly added.
The frightened people in the crowd seemed to relax.
“No,” the man said, “this is the place that exists between the world you came from and the world into which you are headed.”
Murmurs rose among the crowd. When Eliot heard this, he immediately saw the logic of it. He realized why the valley had the aura of something both desolate and peaceful. It was the place between places.
He felt Eliza tug at his hand. He looked down into her questioning eyes.
“I don’t want to go to another world,” she said.
“It’ll be fine,” he whispered. “Don’t worry.”
The guide began to speak again. “But before you go on to the world that awaits you…” the man paused a moment, observing the crowd, preying on their anticipation. “…it is your right to be granted an opportunity.” He smiled.
Eliot found something about that smile unsettling, almost as if there were a malignant thought at the root of it. But then he was looking at the man from far away, and the light was just odd enough to play tricks.
A man’s voice rose up from somewhere in the crowd: “What’s the meaning of all this mystery? What the hell kind of place is this, anyway?”
The guide shifted his eyes through the ranks of people, all dying to know what he was going to do or say next. Eliot could tell that the man was enjoying himself. The guide turned his head toward the valley.
“Bring up the first glider,” he called.
A sound came from somewhere beyond the edge of the cliff, a sound like metal wheels rolling along on a track. People near the back were standing on the tips of their toes, trying to see what was coming.
“I want to see it,” Eliza said. She pulled Eliot into the crowd.
“Eliza,” he said. “Wait.”
“Come on,” she said, and pushed forward through the ranks, tugging Eliot along with her.
They bumped into someone different at every step. Eliot tried to ignore the irritated looks people gave him as Eliza forced her way through the crowd. He glanced up to see the guide eyeing him from the platform. The man still had that curious smile on his face. Now everybody was looking at them.
“Eliza,” he said. “Please stop.”
“We’re almost to the front,” she said.
He only followed because he was afraid to let go of her—it never entered his mind to hold her back with force.
The sound of machinery grew louder as they neared the edge of the shelf. The people near the front saw them coming and stepped out of the way. Eliot got the feeling that it was not out of reverence or consideration.
Eliza came to a halt as the valley opened before her. Beyond the ledge, the green fields rose and fell like waves in an ocean; the sharp points of smoke-colored rocks broke out from beneath the hills. Eliza looked up at Eliot and smiled.
“That was easy,” she said.
Eliot just stared down at her. Such a strange girl, he thought.
Then he saw the grey edge of something triangular peek above the ledge.
“Looks like a kite,” Eliza said.
To Eliot it looked like a hang-glider, only bigger and different in a way he could not explain… something about its oversized frame perhaps. It was being brought up by a rising platform that looked metallic, only it didn’t reflect light because there was no light to reflect. The wings of the glider stretched out beyond the edges of the platform.
Eliot heard the metal wheels lock as the platform leveled with the edge of the flat shelf. There was a boom that resonated in the cliffs at all corners of valley, then died out somewhere among the empty glades and scattered rocks. The glider rested in silence.
“Does it really fly?” Eliza asked. Eliot started to answer…
“Magnificently,” a voice said.
Eliot and Eliza both looked up to see the guide standing before them; he’d come down from his pulpit to walk among his sheep. He smiled at the little girl.
“But don’t take my word my for it,” he said.
The guide looked up at Eliot and frowned. “So you are to be the first to fly it?”
“Uh… I didn’t…”
“He was in the back of the group the whole time,” a voice spoke from behind. It was the same voice that had spoken out earlier.
Eliot turned to see a man scowling at him from the front line. The man stepped forward.
“He shoved his way to the front only a second ago,” the man said. “Hell, you saw him do it. Why should he get to fly it first?”
“He’s right,” Eliot said. “We did push our way to the front. It wouldn’t be fair… and besides I’m not sure why I would even want to fly it.”
“Why indeed?” the guide said. “For where would it take you?” The guide stepped past Eliot and addressed the crowd. “I spoke of an opportunity. Here it is.” He motioned to the glider.
“On the other side of this valley,” the guide continued, “there is a tunnel.” He pointed to the dark spot Eliot had seen earlier when he had emerged from the cave.
Eliot looked back at it, noted how small it seemed. To accommodate something as big as the glider meant that the tunnel was a lot farther away than the eye made it appear.
“This tunnel leads back to the world from which you all came,” the guide said.
“You mean back to our lives?” the man from before asked. “We can go back to living again?”
“If you make it through,” the guide said, the lack of confidence evident.
“What happens if one of us goes and doesn’t make it?” the same man asked.
Eliot noticed the guide brighten at this question, almost as if he had been waiting for someone to ask it.
“If you do not succeed…” the guide looked over at Eliot, who was standing off from the rest of the group. “Then you die the real death,” he said.
A shudder went up through the crowd. Whispers and murmurs rose together and blended into a single, inarticulate voice.
“My daddy is on the other side of that tunnel,” Eliza whispered.
“You don’t know that for sure,” Eliot said.
“Yes, I do,” she said.
“Those of you who are unwilling to take the risk,” the guide said, “will accompany me to the next world, where you will be dealt with justly. Of that I can say no more.”
“Eliot,” Eliza said, her voice pleading. “I don’t want to go to the other world. My daddy is not there.”
Eliot stared at her for a while, thinking. Then he looked back at the glider. The great wings seemed to linger in air, sometimes lifting at the slightest force of wind beneath them. Once, the glider leapt up as if to fly, but the ropes tying it off at the bottom held it. It settled again onto the platform as the breeze dwindled.
“Is there only one glider?” Eliot asked. He remembered the guide had called it the first glider.
The guide laughed. “Good god, no. There is one for every person here. But, usually no more than one ever goes out.”
“Why is that?” Eliot asked.
“Because nobody ever wants to follow the one who failed, especially after they see it. So, who will be the first to fly?” The guide turned back toward the people. The same man who had complained about Eliot pushing through the crowd stepped forward.
“I’ll fly it,” he said.
“Ladies and gentlemen,” the guide said, “our first volunteer. Your name, sir?”
“Crowe,” the man said.
“Mr. Crowe. If you will follow me, please.” The guide led Crowe onto the platform.
Eliot felt his sleeve being tugged.
“What is it?”
“See what?” Eliza asked.
“What are you talking about?”
She sighed. “He said that nobody ever wants to fly after they see it. What do they see?”
Eliot thought for a moment. “I don’t know,” he said.
As soon as Crowe was secure in the glider’s harness, the wind began to blow hard, pushing up against the wings. The glider leapt up into the air and hung there, pulling the ropes taught.
“You’re right,” Eliot said. “It does look a lot like a kite.”
“Let her go,” the guide called. The ropes uncoiled by themselves and fell back to the platform. The glider shot out over the valley and rode the wind over rolling green hills. The guide walked back over the platform and stopped close to Eliot.
Eliot watched the glider get smaller as it traveled into the distance. It wasn’t long before it looked like a speck in comparison with the dark spot, which now appeared like an open mouth in the broken face of grey cliffs.
Then Eliot saw something move inside the mouth… or thought he saw something.
“What was that?” he asked.
“What?” Eliza replied.
Eliot narrowed his eyes on the far-away cave. He searched for several moments but didn’t see anything.
“What was what?” Eliza asked.
“I saw a shape inside the cave, like a shadow or something.” He looked over at the guide. The man stared blankly across the valley, seemed inattentive to what Eliot was saying.
“I see it,” Eliza said.
“Where?”
“It’s gone now,” she said. “It did seem like a shadow, though.”
“Like black outlined against black, right?” he said.
“Yes,” she said.
The glider was close to the tunnel now. Eliot turned toward the guide.
“You didn’t tell him everything.”
“Didn’t tell who everything?” The guide continued to stare out into the valley.
Eliot gestured toward the glider off in the distance. “The man—Crowe.”
“I made the risks known,” the guide said. “And then he chose.”
Eliot turned away, disgusted. More and more he found himself hating this place… this desolate place with no sky and no light and—
“Eliot,” Eliza cried, “Look!”
Eliot looked out over the valley just in time to see it erupt from the darkness. The wings unfurled to reveal the muscular, bird-like legs curving down toward buckled claws. The skin was as black as obsidian yet dull as ash. The narrow head coned up behind the spine just like…
“A pterodactyl,” Eliza said dully.
Eliot heard her speak but could not lay hold of her words. He could barely comprehend what he was seeing. He felt like a child and an old man all at once and neither of them resembled the Eliot he thought he was.
He watched the glider turn away from the winged monster, then saw it bounce through the air in an unruly manner. It flew as though it were in a panic.
The beast brought its wings up and snapped them down, folding them inward with ageless grace. The glider begun to spiral downward, its flight broken by the new force of wind. The beast swooped down, caught the glider in its claws and in one motion tore it apart. Shreds of lacerated fabric floated down and disappeared beneath the hills.
The creature never roared or gave any kind of cry. It flew back toward the cave; the only sound came from the resonant beating of its wings.
“Eliot…”
Eliza’s voice seemed to come from somewhere far off. He looked down at her, saw that she was in tears again.
“What?” he said, and found that he too was crying. “What do you want me to say? That everything is going to be all right? Well it’s never going to be all right…”
“Eliot…” She began to cry harder.
“Because it was never meant to be all right,” he said. “Nothing is all right.” He squeezed her tiny arm. She stared up at him, helpless.
“Because in the end,” he said, “it’s always the same goddamn monster. So stop standing there expecting me to sing you back to sleep. I’m not your father. I’m not…”
Without thinking, he fell down into her arms, hugging her as if she were his. Her tears seeped through the fabric of his sweater, felt cold against his shoulder.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “I didn’t…”
“I know,” she said.
He took her hands in his and looked into her eyes. “I’m going to get you out of here,” he said.
Eliza only nodded, then looked up at something behind him. Eliot followed her gaze, turned to see the guide staring down at them. To Eliot, he appeared perplexed, as if he’d never seen two people crying before.
The guide abruptly turned toward the people, standing like rows of headstones and staring out into the valley.
“Who will go next?” the guide asked. The crowd rustled; a bed of dead leaves suddenly windswept.
“We will go,” Eliot said, rising to his feet. The guide looked over at him, then down at the girl.
“Both of you? At the same time?”
“Yes,” Eliot said. “Is that against your rules, as well?”
“There are no rules,” the guide said. “But if it is to be both of you, then both must choose. What is the girl’s choice?” He stared down at Eliza while waiting for her to answer.
She looked up at Eliot, saw him smiling at her; it was the first time she had ever seen him smile.
“It’s whatever you want,” Eliot said.
For the first time, Eliot realized that he was happy—happy that he had found her, or that she had found him. Without her, he would have been like all the other empty souls standing out in the crowd: lost, alone, afraid.
Eliza smiled back at him, her eyes still aglow with tears. “I want to go home,” she said.
“Very well, then,” the guide said, then turned toward the platform. “Bring up the next glider,” he called out. The rumble of machinery echoed down into the valley as the platform began receding into the precipice.
“Are you out of your mind?” a man from the crowd said to Eliot. “You won’t stand a chance against that… that monster.”
The guide stood by calmly, waiting. Eliot started to say something, but was cut off.
“I’m not going to let you take that little girl,” a woman near the front cried. “You’re insane and she doesn’t know any better. She’s only a child.”
Eliot just stood in silence, holding tight to Eliza’s hand.
The woman spoke to the guide. “If he wants to go and get himself torn to pieces, then that’s his affair. But he can’t take her. He can’t.”
Seeing that the guide made no attempt to respond, the woman stepped forward and stretched out her hand toward Eliza. “Come here, sweety.”
Eliot looked at Eliza. “Stay by me,” he said.
“Don’t you say another word to her,” the woman snapped. “Sweety, please come here.” The woman stepped closer.
“I’m going with Eliot,” Eliza said. The woman was about to say something else but the guide stopped her.
“The girl has chosen,” he said. “Now get back if you will not fly.”
“You can’t just—”
“I said, get back.”
The woman looked down at Eliza, then narrowed her eyes as she looked up at Eliot. She turned and went back to her place among the crowd. Eliot saw a man turn to her, heard him say: “Poor girl. It’s really a shame. You did the right thing, though.”
“They don’t understand,” Eliza said. Her voice sounded older as she spoke under her breath.
“No,” Eliot said. “They don’t.”
“This way,” the guide said.
Eliot turned to see that the next glider had been brought up. He and Eliza followed the guide onto the new platform.
“The girl will have to ride atop your back,” the guide said. “And she’ll have to hold on.”
“Can you hold on?” Eliot asked her.
“I’ll have to,” she said. “I won’t go if I have to fly by myself.”
Eliot climbed into the harness and wrapped his hands around the guiding bars, tried not think about how he was going to fly the thing. Eliza climbed onto his back and wrapped her arms around his neck, then fastened her legs around his back.
“You on?” he asked.
“Yes.”
Eliot looked over at the guide. “I guess we’re ready,” he said.
The guide just stared at him. Eliot saw that the man’s curious smile had found its way back to the surface… only this time there was something different about it.
The wind swept under the wings and the glider lifted, causing Eliot to center his gaze over the fields—the cave looming in the distance. He felt Eliza’s arms and legs tighten around him. The subtle leap made his stomach rise; he had never been fond of flying.
“Set her free,” the guide called. The ropes holding the glider fell away.
Eliot could feel the wind beneath them, lifting them up high above the valley and pushing them forward with great force. Flying was easier than he had expected—all he had to do was hold on.
“You all right?” Eliot called, tilting his to the side.
“Really cold,” she said, raising her voice above the hum of wind.
“Me too,” he said. “Just don’t let go, all right?”
“I’m not going to let go.” She sounded irritated.
The glider rose higher and held its course toward the cave, which was growing larger. The rocks and boulders in the valley looked like pebbles. Eliot tried not to look down. He kept his eyes on the cave. They were almost there.
“Eliot,” Eliza said.
“What is it?” he yelled back.
“I don’t think we’re going to make it,” she said.
“We will,” he said. “Don’t worry. Just hang on to me.”
“Eliot…”
“Yeah?”
“Nothing.”
The glider lifted higher as another gust of wind pushed up against the wings. The cave opened before them, a stygian maw ascending into their heaven… or descending into their hell. For a while Eliot peered hard into the nearing dark—at last he saw the shadow move.
The beast dropped down from some high place in the tunnel, its wings folded back behind it, and shot toward the glider like an arrow. Eliot was startled by how large the creature was; its head alone was the size of their glider, perhaps bigger.
He felt Eliza bury her head into his shoulder.
Eliot looked for the eyes—he wanted to look into the eyes of this terror before he conquered it… but there were no eyes. Where eyes should have been, there were only black folds of calloused skin.
The creature was blind.
“My god,” Eliot said.
“What?” Eliza cried, barely lifting her head.
“I know how to beat it,” he said.
“How?” she cried.
Eliot could not believe what he was thinking, could hardly bring himself to say it. He saw the beast’s wings rise up high into the air.
“You have to let go,” he said.
“What? You’re insane, Eliot. I’m not letting—”
The wings came down. The blast met them head-on and sent the glider spinning backward. Eliot looked away from the whirling horizon, focused on harnessing the undercurrent. After a moment, he brought the glider back up to ride the wind, then turned it around to face the cave. He saw the beast fly upward and then dive after them.
“Eliza,” Eliot said, “We don’t need the glider. Let go.”
The beast swooped over them, claws outstretched. Eliot pushed his weight forward, diving low out of the monster’s path. The glider plunged toward the hills and shot upward. He looked back to see the beast coming around, its wings flattened against the grey world behind it.
“Eliza,” he said, “I can’t keep this up. You have to trust me.”
“I’ll fall if I let go,” she cried.
“That’s just it,” Eliot said, “You can’t fall—not here. No rules, Eliza. It’s all one big trick. You can fly out on your own.”
“Eliot… I…”
Eliot felt a shadow rise over him, felt it swallowing the glider. He didn’t see it, but he knew it was there.
“Eliza,” he yelled, “Let go!”
He felt the weight on his back lift off… for a moment he wondered if he had done the right thing in telling her to let go. Looking to his right, he saw a little girl flying through the air, her hair blown back.
“That’s it, Eliza,” Eliot cried. “Now fly home! I’m right behind you.”
He watched her vanish into the cave’s enveloping dark, then turned the glider down and to the left just as he felt the shadow enfold him. He pulled at the bands securing him to the harness, was able to get the first one loose.
The claws tore through the wings. The glider lurched to the side as the beast caught it and lifted it up toward its slitted jaws. The creature bit down on the wing, then the metal frame. Eliot looked up into a fold of black skin.
He didn’t pay any attention to the sound of fabric tearing, the razor-tipped teeth gnawing away the metal braces. He unstrapped the other band from around his leg and fell free.
He felt the cold wind rush against his chest. For a moment, he thought he was going to keep falling until his body would be thrashed against some jagged rock in the field below. But flying came so naturally, so quick. All he had to do was ride upon the wind and let it carry him to freedom.
He never looked behind him to see if the monster was following, but kept his eyes on the tunnel. As he flew under cover of the cave’s top rim, he could hear the sound of metal rods snapping as the beast tore the flying machine to ruin.
Eliot drove deeper into darkness until he saw the tunnel curve up toward something… something that had the look and feel of light. As he rose toward it, he thought he heard a shrill cry coming from over the plains outside the cave.
Then the light caught him and he forgot everything. On the other side, his daughter was waiting for him.